you can try applying a nude lipliner lightly over your entire lip top and bottom or applying foundation to your lips and then putting on a nude lipstick or lipgloss. this may help to tone down the redness in your lips.
I haven't tried the Benefit Lip Plump, but it sounds like it's worth a shot. I personally just use nude colors to tone my natural lip color down - some faves are MAC C-Thru and Underage lipglass, Prestige Waterproof l/l in Oak, and MAC Fresh Brew lipstick. HTHS!
Originally Posted by ikebana Another vote for C-Thru! Also, try priming your lips with a bit of concealer/foundation to reduce the redness. Great tip... it works very well... and also helps it stick to lips a bit better