I have eyes like yours, so I know how hard it is to wear eyeliner
/emoticons/
[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> If you want to look more natural, I would:
*go lighter on the highlighting and contouring (nose, eyes, cheeks, etc)--you have a nice bone structure to begin with!
*your eyeliner is a little too obvious for my taste. I actually think part of the problem is that the liner isn't opaque enough--it looks looks gray rather than dark black. Instead of using a pencil liner, I would actually recommend a gel liner. You can find them everywhere, even your local drugstore. I would recommend buying a separate liner brush, since the ones packaged with gel liners aren't that great--I'm using one from Target that works perfectly (it was like $3). That way, you can get better pigmentation with nice precision. I wouldn't line so heavily on the bottom, since that looks a little obvious--instead, smudge some dark shadow for a smokier, softer look.
-Follow the eyeliner with the natural shape of your eyes, so that it's just barely visible when you have your eyes open. Build it a little further up the further you go out, and extend it past where your eye ends. Using a small brush, smoke it out with a black eyeshadow. Not too much further above the eyeliner though.
*
http://www.specktra.net/forum/thread/58941/make-eyes-longer-smoky-eyes is really helpful! It helps to wear falsies too. I would recommend ones with lashes that criss-cross, and have a thicker band. Use more natural-looking lashes to avoid looking drag. They're a bit tricky to apply at first, but practice makes perfect
/emoticons/
[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> if you want your eyes to look longer, extend the lashes further out than where your natural lashes end.
*Use warmer eyeshadow tones. The Urban Decay Naked palette has soft, warm/shimmery browns. Purple would also look nice. I wouldn't contour the eyeshadow to fake a crease--rather, follow your natural eye shape and smoke it out. Highlight the inner corners of your eyes with a nice shimmery peach/gold/pink; lightly line 2/3rds of your lower line with it, and use a dark shadow for the outer 3rd.
Hope that helps! Post more pictures
/emoticons/
[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />