Why didn't you just ask me? hahah..
The one and only red eyeliner I've ever liked (I've tried a lot and threw them away they were THAT bad) :
BIOTHERM Define Eyes 105
Surprised? Well, they came out with a red eyeliner last Spring, I hope to heaven they still have it. I think I may be the only person in the world who knew it was an eyeliner and uses it as an eyeliner. For all your /goth/punk needs, just ask me. I know about all the crap and good stuff. Check out also Krylon and Ben Nye, really nice neon shadows and possibly have other colors of liners.
EDIT.. you said reddish orange... DANG! This one is pink/red. Well, it's nice! I can't find it anywhere though, I looked online at the official Biotherm site and it looks like it's been disc. I guess I will keep lookin too, because I need some new colors. Yoou may want to check out Rimmel's Red Dynamite lip liner, I have used it as a lliner before, it worked ok!