Oh my god they emailed me back! Here's what they sent me:
Hey Jamie, So sorry for the lack of communication on our part. It seems like some wires were being crossed with us and our shipping department regarding your giveaway items. However this is not an excuse and for that I want to sincerely apologize for this, we take full responsibility and I can't tell you enough how sorry we are. I am so glad this was brought to my attention. I totally understand any frustration you may have experience due to this issue. From the bottom of my heart I am so sorry that we were not more on top of things. I would love to take this chance to make this right for you. I'll be personally taking care of your order and making sure it is fulfilled and shipped. I know this does not make up for the delay but I would love to add 5 extra liquid lipsticks to your package, so if there are any other colors you have had your eye on please let me know. Again I want to apologize for the issue with your giveaway prize, and to also thank you for bringing it to my attention. We will 100% be taking your feedback and experience very seriously and it will be our main topic of discussion on our next meeting. We hope to continue to improve and to make sure this does not happen again. I do hope you enjoy our cosmetics. As soon as I hear back on the extras, I will get you a tracking. Let me know if you have any questions or concerns. Thanks so much and have a great day Katrina Farnsworth Co-Founder/CEO SweetPea & Fay Cosmetics I'm happy that it seems like she wants to make this right. I really hope she follows through. I still don't feel great about how they've handled this up to this point, but I'm glad that they are (hopefully) going to make it right. We'll see what happens.