I also agree that look #1 is much better suited to a prom than look #2. I love your dress; it's very distinctive and the color is beautiful. It will look lovely paired with bolder makeup. I hope you have a great time!
I like look 1! I think especially for photos, it's better to wear a little bit more color and makeup than you would for everyday. I really wish I had done my makeup more dramatic for my prom, because I just did my everyday makeup and it just doesn't look very special in the photos.
I first one is what I really like. Eman is a great makeup artist and I like her work. I have seen her video doing that makeup and it's really very pretty! It'll suit your dress well and will surely look good on you /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />