Angels Heavenly, hands down and my boyfriend loves it on me. I was desperate to try their Halo and Divine and they didn't smell as pretty to me, until the drydown, both smelled like Heavenly! I also smelled the Pink which seems like a nice scent, I'm not a big fan of the Garden scents, except Vanilla Lace.
My favorite VS scent EVER was Tranquil Breeze, but they discontinued it a few years ago. My current favorite is Love Spell. I was a big fan of Amber Romance but I used it so much (including shampoo and conditioner) that my nose doesn't pick up on how lovely it is anymore.
The people who work at VS call Love Spell "Love Stinks" because either you like it or you dont and it you do you evetually wont cause it is so sweet that is wears on you fast.
omg yes!! i used to LOVE love spell in high school and i bought a new bottle before i moved just because i figured i would still like it--i went to spray it the other day and it made me nauseous...trying to off-load it on my little sister.
i like crisper/"clean" (is that the word for it?) scents now like b&bw "cotton breeze" or whatever the name is.