Originally Posted by
missnadia /img/forum/go_quote.gif Beyonce is just like every other pop starlett out there: overpriced and overhyped. I wouldn't even dream of relying on MTV for a talent / R&B fix when I need one. That's how people are, they need somebody to adore, they need idols, and right now Beyonce happens to be "it".
That said, I don't think she doesn't have any talent at all, just that people tend to overhype stars way out of proportion, and Beyonce isn't the first one to be taking advantage of that. I used to love the old DC group, ever since their first album. They had nice songs and decent videos. Beyonce's voice in high doses has always been annoying to me though, like hearing her a capella would just make me cringe. But it can come out alright if it's properly accompanied. That said, her latest songs really can't compare to what old DC used to make. I just don't like the new style, they sound just too plain to me, and they're not even catchy at all compared to the other "pop" stuff that's out there!
Those people that say that she's original with the half-assed work she puts out need to take a good look outside of what the mainstream music media feeds you. People like Kelis and Syleena Johnson and many more don't get half the respect they deserve for their musical talent thanks to all the attention being misdirected elsewhere.
That covers my opinion of her with respect to music. And I think she needs to stick to singing and batting her eyelashes in her videos, cause man, she can't dance for shit! In the videos she looks stiff, it's blatantly obvious that she's just following somebody's instructions, and has no grace or feel for the moves on her own. It wouldn't even take a Rihanna to outdance her stickman moves.
As for Rihanna.. I've always taken her for what she is: a cute entertainer with average vocals and catchy songs. I listen to her cause her songs are dancy and I like her videos cause she's cute overall, but she wouldn't be one of my favorites as far as overall musical talent.