I got my box yesterday. It turns out it was just an ok box:
Cargo shadow stick: the picture on my box page had 3 nice, neutral colors & I would have been happy with ANY one of those colors. Image my surprise when I opened my Birchbox to find an electric turquoise color pencil. My teen daughter loves it though & she immediately took it. So, it worked out.
Loreal Mythic Oil Masque: this sample is huge and smells really nice. I hope my hair does well with it when I use it.
ModelCo. lip liner: No one in my house will use this one. Not BB's fault, just not for me. Trading it.
Paula's Choice C15 Super booster: this smells weird, like medicine & I don't know if I will be putting it on my face.
Ren glycol mask: My PYS - have used before and love it.