I have such mixed results with the Wet n Wild shadows. I always see people fawn over them and I get sad that I just don't get results as amazing as others seem to!
I do think their neutrals tend to be nicer and more pigmented than their brights. I got the Pop Art collection because I could NOT resist those colors, but in use, I find them lackluster...not TERRIBLE, but nowhere near as pigmented as I had hoped! So when it comes to cheap shadows, I mostly stick with Coastal Scents, because at least for me, they are consistent!
I do like the ColorIcon eyeliners, I use them on my lower lid for some color.
/emoticons/
[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />