I have a bit of a love/hate relationship with this mascara. At first I really didn't like it, but then I realized I picked up the "wrong" one. I went back and bought a waterproof tube, and I like it a bit more. I wouldn't say that I LOVE it, but it's growing on me.. very, very slowly. It doesn't clump on my stick straight Asian eyelashes, and it does add some length and volume (for myself), but it's definitely not become my HOLY GRAIL item.
From what I can tell, this mascara really just depends on the person's own lashes.. I guess like anything else. It's just such a bummer that it's not as AMAZING as all the ads and commercials make it out to me.