Red or very dark/bright lippies (too harsh for my pale coloring)
Nude and brown lippies (washes me out)
Black eyeliner (too harsh)
Yellow/gold eyeshadow (though gold sparkles in another color is ok)
Really shimmery blush (because my oily skin is already shiny)
Also, I don't really like how blue, gray, pink, and purple eyeshadow look on me (browns and warm colors make my eyes pop more), but I do wear them on occasion just for something different. Hubby actually likes bright colors of e/s on me, even though I think that browns and subtle colors are the most flattering on me...