I bought the Teal and Eggplant (purple) last weekend at Ulta, they had them BOGO so $11 for two isn't bad. I don't think they compare to MAC fluidline because fluidline is a gel liner right? Fluidlines go on a lot easier, they glide over lids, unlike the HIP cream liners. I find that they are more like Smashbox cream liners. I havn't tried the purple yet, but I'm wearing the teal today, it's a very beautiful color, I'll post my FOTD later.