I love the cream eraser! The medium looks dark in the jar, but it goes on clear. I like it better than smashbox because it doesn't get shiney during the day. I also ordered a sample of the banana eraser & it works pretty well for undereye circles. I'm not sure I would order a full size banana, but the medium cream eraser is a keeper! I ordered about 20 eye shadow samples. They come in jars and should last a while. I also tried the What Red eraser, but I don't care for it.