My current BF, no way. He doesn't even like to kiss me when I'm wearing tinted lip balm (really lightly tinted!). I put it on a guy I used to date in HS, after we'd stopped dating, but that was because he was in a routine with us and we did a role-reversal theme with the women dressed as men and vice versa. I literally had to pin him in the corner to put lipstick on him, so he got bright fuschia, but he ended up liking the way it felt on his lips. I did eyeshadow on him too.
Also in HS, I put makeup on a guy I was kinda hooking up with. He asked me to b/c girls always told him he would look really good with eyeliner, so I did black liner and some shadow. It didn't look as good as I was hoping it would...his eyes were kinda small so full liner just made them look smaller and you couldn't see their pretty color as well.