I got the Heartleigh nail polish, the Unwash, the Tinties lip butter, the Rituals gel, and the Scalisi cleanser/exfoliator. Great box! They've had three great months in a row! I was not really a fan of November, but they've redeemed themselves in December, January, and February. Let's hope they keep it up!
I was happy to get the Scalisi cleanser instead of the mascara. I'm swimming in mascara from all my subscriptions! My best friend has Glossybox and got the mascara and says it's great, though, so I am a little sad I don't have it. The Scalisi is full size and worth $25. After adding all the prices up (and accounting for the fact that the Unwash is not full size), my box is worth $74.67. The Jelly Pong Pong mascara is worth $22, so boxes that got that instead of the cleanser would be worth $71.67. Definitely worth the subscription price!